Compare Extra ED Pack (Sildenafil, Tadalafil, Vardenafil) with Alternatives
ED Medication Finder
Find Your Best ED Medication
Answer a few simple questions to determine which ED medication may work best for you based on your specific needs and circumstances.
1. When do you need results?
2. What's your main concern?
3. How long do you need the medication to work?
4. Do you have health conditions that might affect medication choice?
5. What's your primary goal?
Your Recommendation
Answer the questions above to see your personalized recommendation.
When you’re dealing with erectile dysfunction, the goal isn’t to take more pills-it’s to find the one that works for you. The Extra ED Pack bundles three common medications-sildenafil, tadalafil, and vardenafil-so you can test them side by side. But is that really the best approach? Are there better, safer, or more cost-effective alternatives out there? Let’s cut through the noise and look at what each option actually does, how long it lasts, what side effects you might face, and what else you could try instead.
What’s in the Extra ED Pack?
The Extra ED Pack typically includes:
- Sildenafil (Viagra): 50mg or 100mg tablets, taken 30-60 minutes before sex. Works for about 4-5 hours.
- Tadalafil (Cialis): 10mg or 20mg tablets, taken 30 minutes before sex. Lasts up to 36 hours.
- Vardenafil (Levitra): 10mg or 20mg tablets, taken 25-60 minutes before sex. Lasts 4-5 hours, similar to sildenafil.
These are all PDE5 inhibitors. They don’t cause an erection on their own. They just help your body respond to sexual stimulation by increasing blood flow to the penis. The pack gives you flexibility-maybe one works better than the others, or maybe you need something longer-lasting for spontaneous activity.
How They Compare Head-to-Head
Here’s how these three stack up based on real-world use, not just marketing claims:
| Feature | Sildenafil | Tadalafil | Vardenafil |
|---|---|---|---|
| Onset of Action | 30-60 minutes | 30 minutes | 25-60 minutes |
| Duration | 4-5 hours | Up to 36 hours | 4-5 hours |
| Food Impact | Delayed by high-fat meals | Minimal effect | Delayed by high-fat meals |
| Common Side Effects | Headache, flushing, indigestion | Back pain, muscle aches, headache | Headache, flushing, nasal congestion |
| Best For | Occasional use, predictable timing | Spontaneous activity, weekend use | Those who didn’t respond to sildenafil |
Tadalafil stands out because of its long window. If you’re in a relationship where timing isn’t planned, it removes pressure. Sildenafil is the most tested and cheapest generic. Vardenafil is often chosen when sildenafil causes too much stomach upset.
Why the Extra ED Pack Might Not Be the Best Choice
There’s a hidden cost to trying all three at once. First, you’re paying for three prescriptions instead of one. Second, you might not get the right dosage. The pack usually gives you standard doses-100mg sildenafil, 20mg tadalafil-but not everyone needs that much. Some men get results with 25mg sildenafil. Others find 5mg tadalafil enough for daily use.
Third, you’re not learning why one works better than another. Did tadalafil work because of its length? Or because you took it on an empty stomach? Without tracking, you’re guessing.
And here’s something most people miss: if you’ve tried all three and none worked, the problem might not be blood flow. It could be low testosterone, anxiety, nerve damage from diabetes, or even sleep apnea. The pack doesn’t solve those.
Alternatives to the Extra ED Pack
What if you skip the pack entirely and go straight to alternatives?
1. Daily Low-Dose Tadalafil (5mg)
Instead of taking 20mg before sex, some men take 5mg every day. It builds up in your system. You don’t need to plan. You don’t need to time it. You just… do. Studies show it improves not just erections but also urinary symptoms in men with BPH. It’s cheaper long-term than buying single-dose packs.
2. Alprostadil (Injections or Urethral Suppositories)
If oral meds fail, alprostadil is the next step. It’s injected into the penis or inserted as a tiny pellet into the urethra. Works in under 10 minutes. Lasts 30-60 minutes. Success rate: 80% even in men who didn’t respond to PDE5 inhibitors. Side effects? Mild pain, bruising, or dizziness. Not for everyone-but it’s a proven option when pills don’t cut it.
3. Vacuum Erection Devices (VEDs)
These are mechanical pumps that draw blood into the penis, then a ring holds it there. No pills. No injections. No prescriptions. They’re FDA-approved, covered by Medicare, and cost under $100. They work for men with diabetes, after prostate surgery, or with severe vascular disease. The downside? It’s not as “natural” feeling. But for some, it’s the only thing that works.
4. Testosterone Therapy
Low testosterone affects up to 40% of men over 45 with ED. If your levels are below 300 ng/dL, adding testosterone can improve libido and response to ED meds. But it won’t fix ED on its own if blood flow is blocked. It’s a combo play-testosterone + low-dose tadalafil often works better than either alone.
5. Lifestyle Changes That Actually Work
Here’s what the science says: losing 10% of body weight improves erectile function in 30% of overweight men. Quitting smoking improves blood flow within weeks. Walking 30 minutes a day lowers ED risk by 41%. These aren’t just “nice to have”-they’re medical interventions. No pill can replace what your body does when it’s healthy.
When to See a Doctor (Not Just Buy a Pack)
If you’re buying ED meds online without a prescription, you’re risking more than money. Counterfeit pills are everywhere. Some contain dangerous doses of other drugs. Others have no active ingredient at all.
A good doctor will check:
- Your blood pressure (ED meds can be dangerous with heart conditions)
- Your cholesterol and blood sugar
- Your testosterone levels
- Whether you’re taking nitrates (which can cause fatal drops in blood pressure with ED drugs)
They’ll also ask about your mental health. Anxiety and depression are major causes of ED-and often overlooked.
What to Do Next
Here’s a simple plan:
- Get a blood test to check testosterone, glucose, and lipids.
- Start with 5mg tadalafil daily for 2 weeks. Track results.
- If no improvement, try 25mg sildenafil on an empty stomach.
- If still nothing, ask about alprostadil or a VED.
- Start walking 30 minutes a day. Cut sugar and processed carbs.
You don’t need to try all three pills in a pack. You need to understand your body. The Extra ED Pack is a shortcut-but shortcuts often lead to dead ends.
Final Thought: It’s Not About the Pill
The real question isn’t whether sildenafil works better than vardenafil. It’s: Why are you having trouble getting an erection in the first place? ED is rarely just a penis problem. It’s often the first sign of something bigger-heart disease, diabetes, stress, or poor sleep. The best treatment isn’t a pill. It’s a conversation-with your doctor, with your partner, and with yourself.
Can I take all three ED medications at once?
No. Never mix sildenafil, tadalafil, or vardenafil. They all work the same way and can cause dangerously low blood pressure, priapism (a painful, prolonged erection), or heart problems. The Extra ED Pack is meant for testing one at a time, not combining them.
Is tadalafil really better than sildenafil?
It depends on your needs. Tadalafil lasts longer (up to 36 hours), so it’s better for spontaneous activity. Sildenafil works faster and is cheaper. If you’re on a tight schedule, sildenafil is fine. If you want flexibility, tadalafil wins. Neither is universally better.
Do ED medications work for everyone?
No. About 25-30% of men don’t respond to PDE5 inhibitors. This often happens with nerve damage from diabetes, after prostate surgery, or if testosterone is very low. If pills don’t work after two proper trials, see a specialist. Other options like injections or vacuum devices are effective alternatives.
Are generic versions as good as brand names?
Yes. Generic sildenafil, tadalafil, and vardenafil contain the same active ingredients as Viagra, Cialis, and Levitra. They’re regulated by the FDA and must meet the same standards. The only differences are inactive fillers and cost-generics are often 80% cheaper.
Can lifestyle changes really fix ED?
Absolutely. Studies show that losing weight, quitting smoking, and exercising regularly can improve or even reverse ED in up to 40% of men. These aren’t just helpful-they’re foundational. Medications treat symptoms. Lifestyle changes treat causes.
Is it safe to buy ED packs online?
Not if you don’t know the source. Over 50% of ED pills sold online are counterfeit, according to the WHO. They may contain toxic substances, wrong dosages, or no active ingredient at all. Always get ED meds through a licensed pharmacy with a prescription.
What to Try Next
If you’re still unsure, start here: book a simple blood test. Check your testosterone, fasting glucose, and cholesterol. Then talk to your doctor about trying 5mg tadalafil daily for two weeks. Meanwhile, walk 30 minutes every day. Don’t wait for the perfect pill. Fix the foundation-and the rest will follow.
Comments
Lashonda Rene
November 5, 2025 AT 00:35okay so i just tried the extra ed pack because my boyfriend said it was a good idea and honestly? i think it was a waste of money. i mean, like, why buy three things when you could just try one and see if it works? i took sildenafil first and it was fine but i felt kinda dizzy and my face turned red like i’d been in a sauna. then tadalafil? that one lasted forever, like i could’ve had sex at 2am and it would’ve still worked at 8am. but honestly, i think the real issue isn’t the pill-it’s that we never talked about why this was even happening in the first place. maybe we’re just stressed? maybe he’s not sleeping enough? maybe he’s eating too much pizza? i don’t know. but i think we should’ve started with a walk or something instead of a pack of pills.